Mirror Misread
By JBD.
Antonia was way too reserved to move fast or want to try anything extreme. Extreme for Antonia was having had sex before marriage, let alone while still in high school- even if they were both seniors and 18.
Antonia is, by all reasonable accounts, stunning. She has long blonde hair and a slim- almost non-existent- waist. She has the most bottomless green eyes you’ve ever seen. They are the color of the forest in summer with a slight glow; you can stare into them all day long. Her smile is unfortunately too infrequent, but when it comes, she lights up a room with it. Her boobs are not big at all, being just barely a b-cup, but I’ve never had reason to complain.
But even if everything else were to be forgotten, her butt would leave an impression that only a dead man could forget. Because of her tiny waist, her hips flared out to make her butt look much larger, but because it wasn’t big when seen independently when she bent over, it made everyone- girls included- stare. I’m convinced the saying, ‘bounce a quarter off that,’ was invented for her butt.
Everything I knew about Antonia changed when I opened my back door that day. Everything. I heard her knock lightly on the metal screen door, but I was in the middle of a level of my video game and shouted, “One minute!” There was another knock, but I was still engrossed in the game. A third, louder knock on the door got my attention, and I rushed to a save point. I overwrote my previous file and shut down the game system. The fourth knock was on the wood door, not the metal screen door. Part of my mind registered that that was unusual for Antonia, who felt it presumptuous to open a door before being invited in, but I managed not to let that thought obsess me.
My dog Moose tried to beat me to the door, but I grabbed his collar and shut him in the kitchen because he was too hyper around Antonia. He jumped up and down whenever she was around. He’s a mixed Boxer/Great Dane and goes at least 100-120 pounds. That makes him about the same weight or a little more than her, and he frequently pushed her aside or knocked her over.
Closing the kitchen door, I could finally open the back door. To say that what I saw surprised me would be an injustice to the word “surprise.” Antonia, my Antonia, was standing there with knees shaking, her body twisting, and her head looking around, naked. Not a stitch of clothing. No shirt, skirt, shorts, shoes, or socks. Nothing. I froze. I think I made a weird sound in my throat, but I am not sure.
Antonia pushed me aside and strode into the house. I followed her with my eyes, but my body was not taking any orders from my brain and kept holding the door open. Now that she was inside, all her nervousness seemed to evaporate, and I saw the slightest hint of a mischievous smile on her shoulder as she entered the living room. My brain was still slowly processing what my eyes were visiting, so it wasn’t until she’d turned the corner and exited my sight that it finally dawned on me that she had something written on her back and hips.
Now, my curiosity got the better of my body and demanded that I stop being a fool and follow her. I had to read what was written there. That, not her nakedness, got me moving.
I guess I should explain a little bit about myself before you jump to conclusions about me. I’m an idiot. I mean, not really, but it’s what many people think about my behavior. I get caught up in minutia and can’t let things go. I’m probably pretty smart, but I never really put much effort into school, so it doesn’t show there. I’m lucky to bring home C’s, and my report card is often filled with D’s. Despite this, I have never once failed a test in school. I just don’t do homework except math, so I could never get above a C. My teachers certainly do not think I’m worth any special effort- except maybe Mrs. Forner, who tried to push me to write more. They just give me the grades and move me on. They know I’m not cheating, so they concentrate on the other students who need help.
But people think my obsessions indicate low intelligence, as strange as they can be. My occasional stellar examples of a lack of common sense do not help this opinion. For example… I locked my locker with the key inside it. The standard solution would be to go to the administrative office and have them unlock it. My answer was to find a book in the library (a great one by someone at MIT), read up on picking locks, find some tools in the metal shop and woodworking that would work, and spend three days working at different times to figure out how to pick the lock. When I finally got the lock open, it never really worked again, and pretty much any key that fit would open it after that. I must emphasize that I wasn’t worried about getting in trouble or afraid to ask. I just didn’t even think of it. I had a problem, and this was the solution I came up with.
On the other hand, I have what some people see as occasional moments of brilliant insight and solutions to problems. I figured out almost immediately how to arrange the collapsing and raising of a set for the school play that had failed to work properly in dress rehearsal. And my solution required only two stage people instead of six. Again, I’m not especially gifted; I don’t see things quite like others.
Because of these things, I don’t have a lot of friends. I don’t quite fit in with any group, but I also am not excluded from any group. No one generally hassles me except occasionally for being my usual, but to the slightly weird self. I’m not sure why Antonia started seeing me, and I certainly had been very surprised when she proposed that we officially start dating. Dating was relatively rare in my school and harkened back to the old days of pinning a girl. It signified a deeper relationship. I was happy but didn’t know what I’d done to earn it.
So seeing my conservative girlfriend standing at my door naked, watching her walk past me into the living room, finally following her into the living room to see her on her hands and knees, her magnificent butt pointed at me, and reading on her back:
In lipstick or marker, I really should have just followed the instructions. I’m sure she’d have understood a moment of confusion on my part, but any other boyfriend would have been down on his knees and plowed her pussy in a heartbeat.
What did I do? I asked, “Who wrote that on you?”
Antonia turned her head and gave me a skeptical look before answering, “Marci wrote it for me before we left school.” Knowing I wasn’t likely to let up that easy, she sighed and continued, “In the girl’s room before last period.” She could see that I was still going to ask questions because she said, “I wrote something similar on her back last week. And on her front. And her boobs. And right above her pussy.”
“Was it the same?” I asked. Before you wonder what I’m doing, I told you I was an idiot. Yes, I had a hard-on as I’d never experienced, but my curiosity would not let me stop talking.
She lowered her ass and relaxed her arms to get more comfortable. She knew me and knew that it was not her but me. Still, I could tell she was less pleased as she answered, “No. Her’s was far, far more explicit.”
“More explicit?” I asked in shock.
“Yes. Her’s read…” she paused momentarily, “You can’t tell anyone… I’m serious… No. One.” I nodded my understanding, “She had me write. ‘Fuck me like a slut. Use me like a whore. Make me worship your big black cock. Fill me with your seed. Make my loser boyfriend raise your nigger baby. Black cock only.’”
“Wow. That’s messed up.” I answered. “And you let her write on you? How did you know that she wouldn’t write the same things?”
“Well, first, Marci’s been sleeping with Reggie behind Evan’s back for months. They both get a kick out of fucking behind his back. You know she hasn’t even given it up for Evan yet?” I didn’t, but I had enough sense to nod so she’d continue. “Second, I looked in the mirror at it after she was done. I love what she wrote. I want you to screw me like a god and cum inside me.”
Now pay attention and remember again that I told you I’m an idiot. “That’s not what she wrote.”
“What? Of course, it is… I saw it. Well, spunk instead of cum, but the same thing. Will you do as it says or keep asking stupid questions?”
“You sure you want me to do like it says?” I asked her. An idea had clicked inside my head, and I hoped she’d say yes, but I knew I’d not have a girlfriend afterward. If I was lucky, that was the best thing I’d have to happen to me. I could end up in jail. I didn’t think about that right then, but it crossed my mind. It was a sick and perverted thought that I really should have just ignored, but that’s not how I’m wired.
Antonia looked me straight in the eyes. I had one moment of understanding things that others don’t see right away. I knew then that I had completely misjudged her character or something fundamental had changed in her because I knew she would say yes and do whatever I wanted her to do. This would be so bad because the absolute thing I needed then (and many times) was restraint. Without it… with a willing participant… I was sure I would get in real trouble before the day was out. She nodded and quietly said, “Yes.” I think she, too, knew something unexpected was going to happen. I think she knew that something was about to change forever with us.
And it was. The dye was cast. The last thing that could have saved us both was gone. We were doomed, and neither knew how doomed we were. As I said, I sensed this, but all caution was tossed aside with that yes. I could not have stopped myself. Only physical restraint could have stopped me then. I wanted to see what my mind had conjured up in action, and now that I had consent, I could not stop it. Truthfully, even if my parents had walked in at that moment, I would have had to try again. And even had Antonia come to her senses, I would have had to find someone else. I NEEDED to know what I thought that moment was like.
“Stay there,” I ordered. It was not quite a shout, but it was an order, and she looked at me, surprised at the tone change. Then she got back in position on all fours with her dazzling smile marred by the slightly worried expression in her eyes. The mix was intoxicating. I left the living room, repeating “Stay” as I exited. I went to the kitchen and opened the door. Moose hopped up from where he was lying and ran over to me. I grabbed his collar and led him into the living room.
Antonia’s eyes widened as she saw me holding Moose, but I repeated “Stay” again, and she didn’t move. Moose automatically pulled against me and tried to stick his nose in her butt. I let him, and he briefly sniffed and snuffled at her, and then he started licking her thighs, butt, pussy, and crack. Her head shot up, and I let go of Moose, hurried around to her front, took hold of her hand on the floor, and looked her right in the eyes. There was no mistaking the overriding look she returned. Moose’s tongue was affecting her, and she liked it too much to ask me to have him stop. Sure, there was some outrage, maybe even anger, disgust, and humiliation, but the overriding look was pure pleasure.
“Just giving you what Marci wrote on you….” I said.
Antonia’s breathing was heavy, and she made a little mewing sound in her throat. But her eyes managed to convey the question, and I continued, “She didn’t say to screw you like a god. She said to screw you like a dog. This is how dogs screw.” With that revelation out of the way, Antonia shuddered in what I was pretty sure was the beginning of an orgasm. I looked carefully into her eyes to see if it was. I saw her eyes flutter and then the whites of them, and I knew that she was about to pass out as she came. This was normal, but we’d worked out a system to stop it, and I implemented it. I reached up, grabbed her nipple, and squeezed it hard while twisting. She came in a bigger orgasm than I’d ever seen her as her arms collapsed and her ass stayed high in the air.
I looked back at Moose. He was still working at her with his tongue, but his cock was fully exposed now. I went back to him just as he jumped on top of Antonia. He tried to thrust his cock into her but was way off target. I knew this was about to happen, so I was already reaching when he jumped up on her. Before he could quickly try and impale her again, I held his cock and guided it right into her pussy. Antonia’s head shot up off the carpet, almost level with her ass, even though her hands had not moved, and she screamed. She collapsed down hard as Moose thrust over and over again into her. I kept him from pulling out, and soon he was more controlled, and his knot was pushing against her pussy. He was too big to fit easily, but he was determined to do so.
I let Moose do his thing and went back to Antonia’s head. She was panting hard, tears running down her face and dripping off her nose. She was biting her lip and flushed as I’d ever seen her. I leaned down and kissed her on the forehead. I kissed her on the eyes, cheeks, and nose, tasting the salty tears with every kiss. I finally got to her mouth, and we exchanged a series of kisses, which I could barely adequately describe. They conveyed passion, hurt, anger, humiliation, gratitude, pleasure, lust, revenge, and a host of other emotions. Our tongues dueled, and our lips wrestled. Our teeth nibbled and bit. We shared breaths and withheld breaths.
I don’t know how long we made out, but I know when it ended. It was when Moose managed to shove his knot through her lips and embed it in her pussy. Immediately, Moose turned around and locked his cock in Antonia. I watched his body spasming, and he shot load after load of cum into her. While this was going on, Antonia was screaming- and I mean screaming where before had been more a shout of pain and surprise- in a perfect mix of pain and pleasure. I saw her second orgasm coming, but I wasn’t fast enough to stop her from passing out this time because she was lying on her boobs.
To wake her up, I slapped her ass hard. Once, twice, three times, and she didn’t rouse. I pinched her butt cheek repeatedly and still got no response. I moved Moose’s tail, stuck my hand down her ass crack, thrust first one, then two, and finally three fingers up her asshole, and she finally roused. Immediately I felt her sphincter squeeze around me, and her ass shoved back against Moose and me. I thrust in and out of her ass, and in moments, she shuddered in another orgasm. This time, she managed to stay conscious, but only barely.
Moose was done spasming, and now he was just waiting for his cock to pop out. I had seen him mate with a dog before, and I knew from that experience it could take quite some time for that to happen. At least fifteen minutes, if not a lot longer. I’d heard it could take an hour and a half, and if that happened this time, my parents would walk in on us, and no explaining could get us out of trouble. Something about that turned me on as much as it scared me. Weird, right?
I resumed thrusting my fingers in and out of her butthole again until, after about ten minutes, I felt Antonia have a fourth orgasm. She barely was able to stir from it and did not have the strength to lift her head off the rug, but she looked back at me with eyes still full of lust and gratitude. There was no anger now, but I did catch a glimpse of anticipated revenge, but it was distant and more lustful than evil.
I pulled my finger out of her asshole and crawled to her face again. I put my fingers that had been pleasuring her to her face, and she sniffed them once, then put them all in her mouth, sucking them clean. Then she grabbed me around the neck with desperate strength and pulled me into a kiss. Part of me wanted to resist because kissing a mouth that had just licked fingers from the ass was disgusting, but another wanted to taste it. It was awful but beautiful.
We stayed locked in that kiss, me rubbing her sides and butt and belly, her stroking my hair and ears and back. More strength was returning to her, and she lifted her head higher and fully engulfed me with her kisses. There was a desperation in them, and I felt a return of desperation. I wanted to be part of her, and she wanted to be part of me. Our tongues resumed their duel, and my cock was ready to explode in my pants with how this was affecting me.
Finally, I heard Moose “pop” out of Antonia. Before moving, she flipped me onto my back, crawled over me, and plopped her dog-cum-filled pussy onto my mouth. She grabbed my hair and said, “EAT IT!” I didn’t even need the order. I started licking and sucking the doggy cum and juices out of her pussy. “That’s it… eat your dog’s cum. Eat it, you dirty pervert. You dirty dog cum eating loser.” That was it. I exploded in my pants. I came without ever touching my cock, and I came to being humiliated by my girlfriend, who I had just essentially raped by proxy and submitted to horrible humiliation. My hips bucked uncontrollably as I arrived, and there was no way to hide it. Antonia laughed, and I swear I came more because of that.
Antonia continued to smother my mouth with her sloppy pussy and looked down at me beneath her. She said, “Well, it seems like you like doggy cum. Maybe as much as I do. Do you want to eat doggy cum from me again?” I nodded. “Do you want to eat lots of doggy cum from me?” I nodded again. “Do you want to eat my ass?” I nodded, and she shifted to where my tongue was now at her ass. I drove my tongue as deep into her hole as far as I could. I couldn’t see her anymore, but she asked, “Do you want to eat doggy cum from there, too?” I blinked momentarily, then nodded emphatically at the perverse idea.
Finally, she asked a pair of questions I knew were coming, and I both hoped they would come and prayed they wouldn’t. I didn’t know the exact wording, but I was already sure of my answer. “Do you want to have sloppy doggy seconds?” I paused. This was it… I could say no… I could try and re-assert myself and my authority. But I didn’t. To my shame and excitement, I nodded yes. Then the seal-the-deal came, “Do you want to always and only have sloppy doggy seconds from now on?” After everything else, it was not nearly as bad. My cock got instantly hard again as I drove my tongue as deep as it would go up her ass, and both nodded yes under her and tried to say “yes” with my tongue lodged in her.
I’m her bitch. She’s Moose’s bitch. We’re both fucked. We’re both happy.
The End.
*This story has been edited by AI to fix spelling, formatting errors, punctuation, & basic grammar, but the narrative and plot have remained the same. Even with the limited editing done here, it doesn’t always mean a story’s narrative/plot flaws are fixed (That’s the author’s job). Also, AI can be inaccurate at times when editing grammar. The opinions/views expressed in this story (and in any comments) are those of the author and do not represent this site. We support freedom of speech. This story has been previously published on other free sites and is now public domain, which is why we can publish it here.
